Pages

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

Further Thoughts on Leadership Strategy

by Victor Alatorre

Observations
The purpose of this blog entry is to explore my perception on what it takes to be a strategic leader in the area of information technology.  

Successful organizations will invest in people. An investment in human capital will enhance value. According to research, employees only engage 10 to 15 percent of the skills within their organization. Successful organizations allow individuals to expand the application of knowledge, skills and abilities. IMHO, the structure of the organization (like in the State) limits what individuals can do or should do within their job responsibilities. It was true 10 years ago, and it is true today. The added factor today is attrition and cost cutting measures dumping more and more responsibility on those strong enough to sustain the effort.
Organizations will be successful if they are capable of sustaining intellectual capital. We tend to connect intellectual capital with organizational knowledge which is (in itself) fueled by human capital.

In the last few years, those companies that have invested on innovative intellectual assets and human resources have had the most success (Apple, Facebook, Google, etc), however the economy has placed pressure on budgets associated with professional development and research and development.
The "Jack Welsh" strategy was the gold standard which included a philosophy of selecting the right people and allocating resources, while watching the talent rise up. 

Well, 20 years ago, Mr Welsh was regarded as the top manager of GE and one of the top leaders in corporate America. Jack was successful at learning the ways of his corporation and identifying talent and opportunities. He had a strong ability to see strategic value to mergers and acquisitions and to apply the GE way to cut the bottom “10 percenters” every year. This approach included the application of statistical theory to improve process (lean sigma), quality improvement through applied statistical analysis and the HR removal of those that lacked the motivation to improve shared value.
There is enough research covering the complexity of managing “knowledge workers”.  So we ask "What motivates technically savvy people?" Without getting too political, I believe our current employment structure and compensation plan fails to identify value and recognize talent for what is worth to the organization. It limits flexibility and opportunities for growth. I believe our current employment structure provides rigid structures that protects silos for better control and management.

The truth about managing knowledge workers goes beyond compensation and moves into the realm of opportunity, professional development and respect. The respect generated by the work knowledge workers do on daily basis. Respect takes many forms like: recognition an awareness of value provided, ability to get buy-in from administrators, the ability to spend time on new ideas or correct old ones, be allowed to learn new skills, etc.
Essential Leadership attributes were identified as:
  • Technical Competence: Hopefully most people in IT have some technical skills, the article fails to identify the depth of technical skill required to be successful. I would add that ability to learn new technical issues is more important than established technical focus on area. All of us face obsolescence, so keeping up with technical skills is important.
  • Conceptual skill: strategic thinking does not come easy to even upper managers. I have experienced it at many levels. They are too busy managing tangibles. I believe strategic thinking is problem solving on steroids for problems that have yet to be identified. Day dreaming, puzzle solving and skills that are not easily perceived
  • Track Record: A track record is a history of performance or individual action. If the track record is good, then it can “perhaps” forecast future ability. A track record can deceive people into believing that if your track record as a technical specialist can translate into a positive track record as a manager.
  • People Skills: As technical people, we tend to gravitate towards electronic, non verbal communications. I do believe that the promotion process favors extroverted technical people. Good looking extroverts is what fuels the lines of upper management promotion. It is also called presence.
  • Taste: Lets call it “talent development”. The ability of a leader to provide professional development opportunities and challenges is important. Sometimes this goes against the very nature of a manager’s propensity to control and limit. I believe talent development to be the most important element of leadership development.
  • Judgement: Technical people tend to be problem solvers, problem solvers tend to be analytical people, however decisions some times have to be made with limited information. This is where the gut instinct comes to mind. The ability for technical people to make sound decisions in a finite time allocation is important. Sometimes people avoid making decisions, specially obsolete technical managers.
  • Character: I believe this is your value system which is a byproduct of family interaction, childhood and professional experience, and personality. Character is not easily identifiable by interviews or communication, It’s what people do that defines them, not speech. Character cannot be acquired.
I believe the most successful leadership factor has to be character. While we may agree with this statement, character is not something that can be put on a resume or easily identified during an job interview. Character is what drives individuals in an organization to do the right thing when others simply do not play by the same rules. Character is sometimes the missing element in management, so organizations suffer due to the flaws of those leaders driving them. Character is what you do for others when they have no power over you or your future.

In my interpretation, knowledge workers demand the following:
  • Meaning or direction: A leader that knows and communicates where the organization is going, perhaps sometimes shares anxieties without sounding too negative.
  • Trust in and from leader: Ability for managers to back off when needed and step up when an expectation of recognition is needed. Authentic interactions between management and process holders.
  • Hope and optimism: Ability to provide a sense of accomplishment and optimism during a tough implementation and while providing a sense of progress. The energy to stay the course and motivate others for a common cause. 
  • and Results: What is the bottom line’s value and perhaps lessons learned.
Passionate leaders are effective leaders if...

A strong point of view is perhaps one of the factors identified as an elements of a successful leader. However in my opinion POV may also be detrimental to the long term success of an organization. Steve Jobs had a strong POV regarding Apple’s product, however I wonder if many were capable to speak up against his opinion. There are various degrees of passion that without “checks and balances” can be catastrophic to an organization. So we have to ask ourselves the following question: What is the meaning of what we do, what is the value we provide and how do we measure it?

Generating Trust: candor, congruity, perhaps integrity.

We believe in humble leadership which is the ability to manage your ego when dealing with information flow and decision making. The author’s example states that “the face you use at home should be the same face you use at work”. I go further by saying that: Congruity is the correlation between what you say and what you do.

Another term we tend to use is “Candor”. Which is one of those that can cut both ways. It’s the ability to trust that the truth will not get you fired. Candor allows for truthful communication when issues arise that require the honest contribution of all parties involved. In my opinion candor can be problematic because it puts you at a disadvantage when issues arise. Candor works when all parties involved play by the same rules, but it can disadvantage those that show their end game.

Moral Compass:

It is defined as the ability of the individual to use resources and influence for the greater good of an organization. Moral compass is what is missing at many levels of our organization. It is what we need to have to be a long term successful leader. I conclude that organizations often elevate individuals with a moral compass deficits; I call them destructive achievers. In my opinion, while their reigns of “terror” are “sometimes” short lived but, they tend to have a long term delaying effect on progress.

More ideas later.....


Wednesday, June 06, 2012

Social Media (What is it?)

By Victor Alatorre

The purpose of this document is to serve as FYI for social media enthusiast and beginners. Social Media is a general term to describe electronic mechanisms of communications that allow interaction between people. Social Media is the evolution of communication mechanisms that provided interactions for the purpose of information dissemination, customer service exchanges, technical expertise exchanges and customer services. I will focus on how social media can be used to enhance your organizational marketing strategy. Social Media is not a replacement for directed organizational mechanisms and branding. Social Media includes a handful of new technologies, sites and services, but the most prevalent are: Facebook, Twitter, You Tube, Google+, Pinterest and Foursquare, etc.

Facebook
Facebook has become the most established mechanism of communication for students, employees and people in general with a network that includes 845 million people as of February of 2012. As of today, Facebook should be one of the pillars of communication and interactions with current and future customers. You can begin this experience by establishing a page that includes basic information about your program, product and/or service. Once your page is established, it is your goal to create credibility but establishing relationships (awareness) with people in your program and encouraging other to share and “like” your page. Credibility is established by maintaining regular content updates and by getting people to visit your page regularly. Content flow requires discipline and strategy. So it is your goal to maintain updated tidbits of information about your services and events.

Facebook allows for people to interact, share personal information, pictures, updates, information, etc. Facebook for organizations is a marketing and promotional tool; a gateway for “tangible” and “measureable” interactions with business constituents. Having a Facebook page is not a strategy in itself. It requires for all business units and process keepers to come to a common platform for branding and promotion strategy. The what’s, where, when, how’s and who’s have to be established before a credible presence can be established. Content priorities and workflows (outside of Facebook) have to be determined prior to trying to convey a message or idea. A person with Public Relations ability/skills is also a requirement as conversations about your ideas/services/products may quickly spin out of control. The quick and proper handling of concerns by customers is an important element of a social media strategy. Answering questions for subpar services and products in an honest and proactive approach is essential to the management of the online presence.

Twitter (http://twitter.com)
In 2006, twitter was established as an experimental micro-blogging tool allowing users to send (broadcast) 140 character tweets (messages). As of today 300 million users have created an account on this service to share small messages to people “following” them. Twitter has been particularly popular due to its perceive “lightweightness” (agility). The concept of following and followed is important to understand to measure your clout. Clout is the impact on the broadcast of these tweets. The learning curve of tweet requires an understanding of the mechanics behind twitter. An individual tweet allows you to broadcast your message to a virtual room. In order for you to be effective, you need to identify strategies to get people to follow you. You do so in two ways:

Using “#” and “@” tags
Your tweets are information/funny/creative/controversial in nature and have appropriate hash tags. A hash tag is the symbol “#” attached as a prefix to the idea or noun you want to convey. So if you are talking about “Ferraris”, you can use the hash tag to allow the word “Ferraris” or “Italiansupercars” become a trend on the public timeline. If your idea is important to those that read it, you message will trend. The other approach is to use the “@” sign as a prefix to a user you follow or want to respond to. If person wants to respond to a technical question you have, they will add the “@” before your username triggering an identification mechanism.

Following people/organizations/accounts
Another strategy to get people to follow your twitter account is by identifying users that may have similar “interest” or “services” as yours and selecting their accounts to follow. This will create a response from some users to start following your account. Many twitter users do not post much or post too much. A happy balance has to be identified.

Things that could go wrong
Things that you could do to derail the strategy:
  • Too much twittering may turn people (followers) off as their timeline (message queue) may become overwhelmed with your messages.
  • Too many messages about nothing may create a sense that you have nothing to offer. People posting information about when they went to eat or sleep or party may be OK for celebrities and close friends, but it is not a useful or measurable strategy.
  • Too many harsh responses to others. As people scan the public timeline for associated responses to ideas, causes, services and product; people have to be careful not to alienate others with abrasive language.
  • Unless your ultimate goal is political, religious or ideologue in nature; you should limit how much controversial information is shared by you. Anything that is controversial, religious, hate-speech, blunt-coarse, etc. should be left out of your timeline. Once you post something on twitter is there for good. While you can delete messages on your timeline, if others repost your messages, they become part of the broader twitter timeline, which is searchable, and identifiable (traceable).

How do organizations use twitter?
Organizations scan the overall timeline for hash tags associated with their name, products, services and/or befriend people/accounts that are perceived as the topic experts. Technical companies identify questions shared on twitter by end users and respond directly or indirectly through the various mechanisms available. Gurus and experts sometimes respond to people following them when using appropriate hash tags for their topics of expertise. Twitter can create a sense of community by allowing people to react to information in a very decentralized way. People have used twitter to organize people to action as seen in the civil unrest in the middle east, a tool for communication and updates for catastrophic events (japan earthquake) as they take place, sharing of instant communication as events take place allowing for geography/distance to be a non issue.

News bureaus have used the twitter as a stopgap for content as issues or opinions arise. Formal news workflows have been replaced with end users news reporting. So anyone can become an instant celebrity if your contributions on twitter are deemed of value.

YouTube
(http://www.youtube.com)

Former PayPal employees created one of the most successful and controversial tools for video content deployment in 2005 as a place where people could upload video content. The company was acquired by Google in 2006 which allowed for the survival of this website. YouTube is the vehicle most people are familiar with the hosting of video. Prior to YouTube, a person/company would need a pretty substantial infrastructure investment to share video content, as it required enormous amounts of bandwidth. YouTube has had to deal with litigation related to the legality of the distribution of copyright material by non-copyright owners. As large copyright owners realized they could not contain the end user effort to share distributed video material, some content owners establish channels to distributed high quality content in an effort to curve down the distribution of unofficial material.

How can organizations use YouTube
YouTube provides any end user the ability to share, host, provide comments, and qualify video. Organizations create channels where “official” content can be distributed. The use of tags similar twitter allows for content to become popular and become relevant. If the video shared through this mechanism is perceived as noteworthy, popularity may allow for the content creator to become an instant celebrity and jump into more formal channels like TV networks.

Google+
(http://www.google.com/+/learnmore/)

Google launched Google+ in 2011 in an effort to compete with Facebook. I further believe that Google+ is Google’s effort to create a single point of entry for all content it holds on your behalf. If you are a Gmail user, Google created a single login interface for other services it provides like: Google Docs, Blogger, YouTube, Mail, Calendar, Images, etc. Its approach has been controversial because it gives Google the ability to scan your content inclusive of pictures, phone interactions, locations, phone/email directories and brings them to you in a single point of reference. Users create circles where information can be shared with specific people in those groups. It allows for a mechanism of identification based on previous email interactions. So while it doesn't determine who you provide access to your content, it does suggest based on access to your user email directories, who may be of interest to you. Content streams are information flows created by you and those that you follow. Its user experience is a more robust experience than twitter, but adoption requires “trust” and promotion. So far only certain content keepers, organizations and technical people are using Google+ on regular basis. I believe that unless, Facebook makes a user interface experience or privacy mistake, Google+ will be relegated to a second level contender. Organizations are beginning to set pages and content through this channel. Its integration with other services like blogger and YouTube may give Google+ leverage. Furthermore their Hangout (video conferencing) implementation is a very serious contender/alternative to more established video conferencing services like WebEx, etc.

Pinterest
(http://pinterest.com/)

Pinterest is a pinboard style content pining service that became “fully” operational recently with an optional interface with Facebook to provide a rich content experience where people can organize and share photo based content with friends. It allows for people to “Pin” a certain picture or creative idea and to share or choose to “like” the element shared with others. It has been incredibly popular because it allows non-technical people to share and distribute fashion, technology, humor, fitness, and food creations through very simple mechanisms.

Instagram
(http://instagr.am/)

Is a product and a service that allows users (through specialized software) to take, share and modify digital pictures while creating an interface that shares those pictures with twitter or Facebook. It allows non-professional photographers create extraordinary and sometimes nostalgic photographic material. The instagram hosting service allows for people to share, follow others, add comments and like material. In terms of organizational use, instagram is simply another tool for content manipulation and distribution.

Linked-in
(http://www.linkedin.com/)


Linked launched in 2003 is the professional version of a social network site like Facebook allowing for people to associate with each other based on professional role. Inclusive of meeting people, the site allows for the creation of professional groups or associations. It has been the instrument of choice for many marketers that identify potential customers based on perceived role within an organization. People can ask to associate with you and begin written exchanges. It is a very useful tool for people seeking employment, professional advise on specific topics, and professional introduction through third party connections. It has become the most pervasive form of business stalking used by aggressive businesses. The one thing that is different from other forms of social media is that allows for people to know when someone has been reviewing your credentials and public profile.


Blogger
(http://www.blogger.com)

Blogger is one of the oldest social media tools available today and it is owned and hosted by Google. The concept of blogging is simply the effort to maintaining public topic specific content actualized with frequency. The concept of blogging has allowed non-technical people to become content publishers and content distributors. There are an infinite amount of topics and user currently using the technology to create, distribute content with the intent to attract attention and to set credibility for search tool placement. Google bases priority of websites based on influence… Influence is determined based on credibility. Top-level sites are those that can be perceived by the search engines as worthy of attention based on content. Blogging allows ideas distribution through mechanisms that allow content to be linked creating a mesh between content keepers and distribution mechanisms. People seeking specific information about a topic will search Google for information; content in blogs will rise up based on “hits”. The more hits a certain page gets, the more valuable its content will be for Google and its owner. There are many hosting services available for blogging interfaces (Content Management System) like Wordpress, Weebly, LiveJournal, TypePad, Xanga, etc. however Blogger is the only one tightly linked to Google’s overall content presence. One single point of entry for content hosted and distributed through existing mechanisms established by Google.

Monday, April 09, 2012

Transformational Leadership: The New Way for Management

by Victor Alatorre

Introduction

The purpose of this entry is to evaluate the differences and issues concerning transformational and transactional leadership. The management experts clearly define the steps for the development of transformational leaders in the new world economy. Business Management practices in the US have been going through an evolution from a transactional management style to a transformational leadership approach; the manager’s role should be moving from supervisory roles to advisory and visionary roles.

Originally, Adam Smith stated on his book: “wealth of nations” that in order to improve productivity, employee’s roles would have to be simplified. There was no delegation of authority and the default position was to keep the power in the managers and supervisors. Management took a very bureaucratic approach to mass production and employees lacked autonomy. This management style created many strong transactional leaders. Society and business schools brewed managers with this “alpha male” syndrome. The transactional leadership approach worked for about 50 or 60 years, however the US economy started experiencing quality and innovation problems. GM and US steel among others were no longer the leaders in innovation and quality. Their counterparts in Japan had been doing their homework and listening to Deming during their reconstruction periods. The US economy suffered because of this lack of vision. There was a strong need for change in the US management culture during the late 70’s and early 80’s


What is the difference of Transformational Leadership?

The concepts of transactional and transformational leadership were developed by Burns in 1978 to characterize different types of political leaders. Bass (1985) borrowed them to elaborate a new theory for organizational change. As implies Transactional leaders engage their followers in an exchange relationship; the leader give material rewards in exchange for performance and productivity. In many situations where innovation and change are important core capabilities of an organization; transactional leadership is not very effective. As stated by Bernard Bass, passive management by exception is particularly troublesome when managers only intervene when procedure and standards are not been met. He provided the analogy of guiding a train with the driver in the caboose; No one knows where they are going until they hit something on their way. Transactional leaders encourage a “fear-father-son relationship” that motivates employees to do the bare minimum. (Bass 1990)

Transformational leadership is more complex because it involves more than an exchange of work and rewards; it is a mutual exchange of beliefs, needs and values. (Yusuf 98) The primary difference between transactional and transformational leadership is based on a deeper believe system based on justice and integrity and not on punishments and rewards for creative work and performance. Through integrity and justice, the transformational leadership is able to indoctrinate their organizations to develop a new culture. This culture will foster innovation and quality while enhancing the employee capacity for empowerment and ownership. Transformational leaders will develop trusting relationships with all their employees while improving performance and innovation. Employees do not fear expressing concerns or ideas to their transformational leader, thus improving employee’s job satisfaction.

Transactional and transformational leadership styles are multidimensional concepts consisting of a number of sub constructs. Transactional leaders consist of behaviors such as contingent reward, management by exception and laissez-faire. Transformational leadership is based on charisma, inspiration, individual consideration and intellectual stimulation. (Yusuf 98)


  • Previous research and several authors state that transformational leaders exhibit the following five behaviors significantly more often that most other managers: 
  • Visioning: The leaders clearly communicate the vision of the future that is shared broadly by the organization’s members. This vision describes the ultimate outcome for people to achieve, and the leader expresses realistic optimism about the future, with strong expressions of personal confidence and enthusiasm. Transformational leaders lead by example, they serve as role models and behave in ways consistent with their vision. 
  • Inspiring: The leader generates excitement at work and cranks up the expectations with symbols and images. In expressing their vision for the organization, they express their dream in highly motivational language. They give pep talks with high energy, optimism and passion. This behavior builds the confidence of the employees (followers). 
  • Stimulating: The leader arouses interest in new ideas and approaches and enables employees to think about problems in new way (paradigm shifting). Intelligence and clear reasoning are encouraged in order to solve problems. 
  • Coaching: The leader coaches, advises and provides hands-on help for others to improve their performance. The leader listens attentively and expresses encouragement, support and confidence in others’ ability to achieve the expectations of his vision. Leaders give positive feedback for strong performance and effort and give opportunities for other challenging activities. Errors are somewhat rewarded with second opportunities. 
  • Team Building: The leader builds effective teams by selecting team members with complementary skills. They increase trust and self-confidence in the team by sharing information, giving positive feedback, using individual members’ skills and removing obstacles to team performance. (Behnke, Distefano 97) 

Transformational Leaderships Rewards

Transformational leaders are seen as:

  • More effective and more satisfying to work for; 
  • They are usually promoted more frequently; 
  • Develop followers to higher levels of individual and group performance 
  • Produce more innovative products; 
  • Receive more patents for work produced by their people 
  • Lead units that perform more effectively under stress; and 
  • Generate greater risk taking, creativity and tolerance for different perspectives 

Who is a transformational Leader? Maybe Steve Jobs

In the late 80’s and early 90’s Apple had been plagued with ineffectual leadership and poor product lines. The innovation brought by their founders was gone, and their market share was diminishing to one digit numbers. After a series of musical chair CEO appointments and removals, the board of directors from apple made the decision to give Steve Jobs a second chance. Steve was ousted in the 80’s due to incompatibility in management style. He left the company and created PIXAR studios and NEXT Corporation. Both of them had their ups and downs until Steve returned to Apple in 1997 as a consultant and then CEO. NEXT Corp's core capability (Next Step operating system) became the main building block for the development of the next MacOS. PIXAR Studios has been working with Disney Corp on the creation and promotion of high tech computer generated animated films. Both of these projects were part of Steve Jobs’ vision for the future of Apple and PIXAR.

A clear example of transformational leadership behavior and strategy can be seen during the presentations of the Apple’s interim CEO for life. He comes in presenting and introducing new product lines and motivating the crowd and employees. There is however a fear factor against Steve Jobs because many employees still see him as a transactional leader that pouts when things are not done with his vision in mind. There are several books (infinite loop) that speak about his compulsive and sometimes childish behavior in Cupertino during the early 80’s. I feel that his management style has change a lot since he was forced to remove himself from Apple’s headquarters in the mid 80’s.
The Charisma Factor

Charisma is an important element for the development of transformational leadership, however Bass conceptualizes it as purely behavioral phenomenon and an idealized influence. This influence is defined with respect to the follower’s reaction to the leader as well as to the leader’s behavior. The followers identify with and emulate the managers that exercise transformational behaviors. Transformational leaders are seen as having and attainable, trustable mission and vision. (Yusuf 98) Charismatic leaders inspire and excite their employees with the idea that they may be able to accomplish great things with extra effort. Transformational leaders will not stereotype and generalize the demands and needs of their employees. Customization is an important factor for individualized consideration. The third factor is intellectual stimulation by providing the employees paradigm shifts on the way they perform their objectives.


According to the readings and the leadership experts, the concept of Charismatic Leadership is fairly new and can be traced back to the early 70’s. Oberg (1972) proposed divesting charisma of its religious roots and applying to the business management. At the time of political turmoil in the US, Oberg stated that America needed to foster the concept and creation of a new vision in theory of charismatic leadership. Charisma draws its motivational power from the follower’s adoption of the mission and vision of the leaders.

Transformational Behavior Measurement Systems

  • The most extensively used measure for transformational leadership is the multifactor leadership questionnaire (MLQ). Bass’s original measurement instrument contains six items for measuring charisma: 
  • Transmitting a sense of joint mission and ownership (empowerment) 
  • Expressing dedication to followers 
  • Appealing to the hopes and desires of followers 
  • Addressing crisis head on 
  • Easing group tension in critical times 
  • Sacrificing self gain for the gain of the group 

Richard Harris develop a survey to gather information on what senior R&D managers do to make the work of teams more effective. Specifically, they investigated three set of variables: Management Practices, Company Characteristics and Result Measures based on innovation, speed, reliability, quality, cost effectiveness, morale and customer satisfaction. He concluded that there were two sets of teams: Low performance and High performance groups. He studied the correlation of leadership behaviors on the high performance groups and found the following patterns ranked in significance level:

Teams
  • We view customer’s satisfaction as our number one priority 
  • We communicate frequently and informally 
  • We expect people at all levels to be capable of process improvement 
  • Our formal systems and procedures reward team performance 
  • Our informal systems and procedure (culture) reward team performance 
  • We reorganize quickly and with minimal stress 

Management Objectives
  • Clarify responsibilities among related teams 
  • Assessing the effectiveness of team to team coordination 
  • Facilitating resolution of conflicts between teams 
  • Organizing information flow among teams 
  • Ensuring teams have access to the right people at the right time 

Harris concluded that in order to achieve successful organizations and leadership styles, management must assume a longer view as they strive to improve the context and climate for teams and so help to build a team oriented company. Key behaviors associated with this part of their role are: building a shared purpose with all the team’s stakeholders, creating a vision of how the team’s work tie to the organizational strategy and making the best use of a team’s time and energy. (Harris 98) All this concepts are associated with the original idea stated by (Bass 1990) and (Boehnke 1997) for the creation of transformational leadership.


Differences in Culture in transformational leadership


Karen Boehnke and Andrea Distefano among others, evaluated the pattern differences between the US, Northern Europe, Southern Europe, Latin America, The Far East, etc. The main finding was that transformational behavior are universally associated with exceptional performance, with no significant differences in how often the visioning, coaching, and stimulating behaviors were cited. There was a lack of avoidance behaviors that was consistent across cultural groupings. There were some exceptions to rules applied to the concept of transformational leadership. Among them, American groups reported more correcting behaviors associated with exceptional performance than the Far East and Latin America. Americans also included team building more frequently in their explanation of exceptional performance than the Asian counterpart. The Americans also engaged in stimulating behaviors more often than the southern Europeans. Finally, The Far East’s frequency of including recognition was significantly less than the southern Europeans. Managers working on multiple cultural environments should be aware of the limitations of customized leadership styles that may work on the manager’s home office, but may not be appropriate elsewhere. (Boehnke, Distefano 97)

Transformational Leadership in Mexico

Mexico still lives in a Transactional Leadership School of Management. Our workforce is not as educated as their counterparts in the developed world, and the vast majority of Mexican corporations are privately owned. Manager for the most part come from wealthy families, where class status and wealth are more important than empowering employees and giving them ownership of their job objectives. There was a lack of innovation and quality improvement, stemming from government control, strong monopolies, and cultural myopia.

Based on conversations with friends and family currently employed in Mexico, I’m able to determine that management teams do not want their employees to think about empowerment and ownership. Management has a very strict code of conduct and protocol that enables them to cohesive control and monitor the work force at all levels. Only multinational corporations coming from the US and Canada have been able to somewhat implement some level of quality improvement through ISO certifications and such.

Historically speaking Mexico has always been dominated by a strong invisible cast system of haves and have-nots. Mexican people and managers are amazed about the level of innovation in technology coming from the US, yet they do not understand that innovation and quality improvement can be achieved through reforms in the leadership styles and not through ISO certifications. We need to move from supervisory and transactional roles to transformational and empowering roles.

Conclusion
US corporations practicing transformational leadership behaviors are way ahead of their counterparts using transactional supervisory roles. Leadership experts have defined the characteristics of transformational leadership and the steps to achieve a transformational organizational culture. This transformational leadership enables better working environments, and fosters creativity through innovation and quality.



Bibliography

Bernard Bass, From Transactional to Transformational Leadership: Learning to share the vision, Organizational Dynamics Winter 1990 pp 19-32

Karen Boehnke; Andrea Distefano; Joseph Distefano; Nick Bontis Leadership for extraordinary performance, Business Quarterly v61 p56-63 summer 97

Albert Canella Jr.; Martin Monroe, Contrasting Perspectives on Strategic Leaders: Toward a more Realistic View of Top Managers, Journal of Management v23 no3 p213-37 97

Richard Harris; Jan Trescott Lambert Building Effective R&D Teams: The senior Manager’s Role, Research Technology Management 41 no5 28-35 S/0 ‘98

DA Nadler; M.L. Tushman What makes for Magic Leadership; Contemporary Issues in Leadership (Boulder, CO: West View Press 1989): 120-145

W.Oberg Charismatic commitment and Contemporary Organizational theory, MSU Business Topics 20 (1972): 18-32

Philips Podsakoff; Scott B Mackenzie; William Bommer, Transformational Leader Behaviors and substitutes for leadership as determinants of employee satisfaction and commitment, Journal of Management v22 no2 p259-98 96

Francis Yanmarino; William Spangler et al, Transformational and contingent reward leadership: Individual, dyad and group levels of analysis, Leadership Quarterly Spring 98 Vol 9 Issue p27 28 4 charts




Reengineering Management


Reengineering Management
by Victor Alatorre

Summary
Issues of purpose: Managers need to constantly question the “status quo”. Managers should question “why”, “how” and “what for” constantly in order to see successful for continuous improvement. There are three core elements affecting organizations: Paradigms Shifts in the Industry, Communication-Robotic Technology and Government policy and deregulation. Continuous change in the market means continuous change in the organizational needs, thus mangers must seek the constant improvement and redefinition of business purposes in order to remain competitive.

Issues of culture: Successful reengineering requires a change of organizational culture. This organizational change needs to be promoted, applied and sponsored from the top-down. Managers need to change themselves in order to change the organization otherwise BPR efforts will fail.

Issues of process and performance: How do we apply the processes necessary for worker, employee, manager and machine performance? They are what constitute the day-to-day work and must now be subject to the same scrutiny. Champy outlines five core management processes: mobilizing: distribution of human resources around the organization to improve business performance, enabling: empowering and redesigning work in order to meet business objectives and performance, defining: clearly stating the companies goals and objectives from management’s perspective, measuring: determine non-financial ways to measure performance in order to determine employee accountability, and communicating: managing the organization as an open book, while “honestly” expressing the issues and steps necessary for change.

Issues of people: How and where we find the right people to share the vision and mission we need to operate the organization successfully. Questions of hiring, promotion, development, and deployment will need to be addressed by the whole organization and not left to Human Resources People.

The book was written to address Business Process Reengineering (BPR) from the management perspective. It was written to explore Champy’s recent findings on reengineering. The book explores methodology for changing management’s perspective on the way managers think, work, organize, inspire, deploy, enable, measure and reward the value adding operational work. His original book (reengineering the corporation) was written to improve business performance by showing managers how to revolutionize their key operational processes-product development and/or order fulfillment processes. Champy collected testimonies from 150 business managers, and gathered over 18 months of research. Some of these BPR implementation issues are complex and not easy to answer; however Champy uses case studies and corporate surveys to facilitate understanding of corporate reengineering.


His book covers four broad issues:

Note: Champy confirms that these four questions are tough to answer and once answered, tough to accept. People and organizations have a difficult time accepting change.


Champy explores the historical implications of (outdated) management philosophies. Many business people believe the US business world would foster an eternal “smooth sailing” concept, however global competition, technology, market freedom and informed customer choice has turned the business world into highly competitive environment. Customers are educated and unwilling to compromise their choice for quality, service and price. Champy calls it the “Dictatorship of Customariat” or “Market Democracy”. Those corporations unwilling to change would suffer and ultimately die from their lack of vision to face adversity and change.


Champy claims that organizations need to leave behind perfectionist processes for experimental approaches. Dismissing the concept of “getting in right and keep it going” for “getting right and make it better and better every time.” Let go of the control issues associated with upper management, and understand that mistakes are good for the organizational learning process. Managers need to trade the ex-officio authority style for an existential authority. Overthrowing the conservative approach for measuring and control systems based only on financial systems and understanding that some radical new paradigms in measurement and control systems need to be there to provide added value for the consumer. Managers need to let go of the old (adversarial-competitive) approach for management betterment and introduce supportive systems for employee professional development and education. Remembering that some elements of the business world and human behavior can sometimes be unpredictable, vague and a great source for creativity. Management needs to seek multilevel-pluralistic skill levels, multi-goal level enterprising. Moving from corporate protocol and discipline to learned willingness and individual accountability.

Champy’s book is very relevant to this course because it outlines and integrates the following concepts:

Leadership: Champy explains the new role for management. Managers should move from transactional leadership to transformation leadership roles. He defines the new enterprise manager as someone that holds up both a mirror and a lamp to everyone connected with his organization. He shows them how they are now, and lighting the way to what they can become. Champy encourages the new management to abandon the old paradigm of internal focus.

Champy also defines the expertise manager as one who takes responsibility for directing the people and technology in the corporation and integrating them to make his vision a reality. Every organization has a few process experts whose primary contribution to the organization resides on their expertise application. These process managers are good teachers, thus enabling organizational knowledge integration. He promotes the idea of self-management by taking responsibility for one’s own performance and accepting accountability for this newfound freedom. This is probably the most important value that a corporation can promote during a BPR.

Power and Decision Making in the Context of Change:
Champy covers the new decision model based on empowerment by the redefining management work. Old control systems do not work in the new system because they do not measure the same processes. He states that the biggest problem for BPR comes at the level of senior management. Most senior managers refuse change because they believe that organizations change will deny access to the old paradigm of power. If senior management doesn’t comply with the new rules, the BPR effort will dwindle to nothing in matter of months. The CEO will need to reassess the situation and intervene against management in deep denial.

The Nature of Planned Change and Organizational Diagnosis: his book defines organizational diagnosis and change as opportunities for success. If the organization needs reengineering, these big changes must come from a top-down approach and driven by those whose vision is the sharpest. A genuine paradigm shift in reengineering occurs when managers change the way they think and work. Champy states that some business people believe that the old way will not fade away until older managers retire or get ousted. He states that a well-planned BPR effort will probably take a long time (5 to 25 years), however technology is pushing change so quickly that companies cannot afford to remain passive. The dynamic organization needs to rethink the business models for management. Reengineering effort should be based on the notion that organizations are living entities that need constant evaluation and modifications in order to remain competitive.

He is the chairman of CSC index, is the leading authority on the implementation of business reengineering initiatives. CSC index is based in Cambridge Massachusetts and is the management-consulting firm that pioneered the development and practice of reengineering. James Champy is the coauthor of the NY times Best Seller “Reengineering the Corporation” which was published in 1993. His book is one of two required reading materials for Dale Feinauers’s Process and Quality MBA course. Dale is an expert on BPR, thus his assessment and opinion on the quality of our readings provide validity to Champy’s books.

His rationale for writing is based on the need to incorporate a number of things he learned since his first book was published in 1993. It allows him to address some of the questions raised by readers of the first edition. Many people wrote him back with questions regarding the application of his methodology for Business Process Reengineering.

This book’s target market is people in management who are experiencing a reengineering process in their organizations. Champy gives solutions on how to keep the BPR effort alive and how to fix possible downfalls.

In order to appreciate this book, the reader needs to read the first book, which outlines the methodology for Business Process Reengineering. He brings back some of the elements and methodology, but it would be difficult to understand without the other book as a base for personal research.

His observations are based on real business world research and not on virtual business models. Every chapter has a “cases in point” subchapter that outlines real world concept issues and solutions.


Internal Validity
Doesn’t apply because Champy wrote the second book by himself, however he received a lot of editorial constructive reviews from the Harper Business editors.

The author is an expert on BPR. He has been able to experience and apply his knowledge of the subject with many organizations going through reengineering.

I don’t work for a large corporation. It is impossible to BPR in an organization like the Department of Residence Life-Management Information Office because of our size, however some of the concepts could be applied to business processes in my organization. I’ve already applied some of the concepts of empowerment, business process improvement, however my intervention and concept application has been minimal.

I feel that the author’s writing style is very comprehensive. I was able to read the whole book in two nights, and I felt that he reinforced some of the concepts from his first book. I’m extremely interested on BPR, because I hope some day to be involved in a reengineering process for a large corporation.

James Champy clearly understands organizational change and the factors affecting BPR from the management and organizational perspectives. He takes BPR concepts to a new level, while taking into consideration the realities affecting organizations. BPR is a steady long process that requires understanding of all the issues affecting management and organizations going through a reengineering project.


James Champy, Reengineering Management, Harper Business, 1995.

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Lessons from my Leadership Journey


Lessons Learned:
  • At some point in my career in IT, I naively perceived that I was only as valuable as my working knowledge of computers. I believed that the more I knew about computers, the more influential I would become.  Influence is earned through collaborative work and experience, not simply knowing more than others.
  • Winning an elected leadership position requires awareness of presence and self-control.   I needed to become aware of how my actions and temper had an impact on the perception of my leadership ability. Once again, I came to realize that degrees and titles only get you half way to the goal of leadership.
  • When you become responsible for a team or social group popularity is incredibly exciting for decision-making, but when issues arise, you need to surround yourself with people that will tell you the truth. The harsh truth that sometimes the king is not wearing any clothes.
  • Sustainable success requires dedication and a systematic approach to time management and goal setting. Your time is precious. It took me a long time to realize that. I had to become more aware of my distractions and my perceptions of what defined my success.
  • Through my leadership journey, I have had many successes and failures. Successes are the accomplishments you put on your resume as you evolve as a professional. The true valuable lessons in life come from what your actions were after failure. It has taken me a long time to appreciate these simple words: I had to learn to deal with failure, overcome disappointment and redefine opportunity.
  • At some point, I came to realize that I was no longer a young person with a great deal of responsibility. I had to change my perception of self, grow up and change my presence. I used to act as if wearing nice clothes to work was a burden. That my leadership skills and experience would carry me through.
  • Happiness is the support of my wife, the smile of my daughter and the playfulness of my son. They remind me that my legacy is connected to their happiness and ability to survive after I’m long gone.
  • My experience and skills are the byproduct of my leadership journey. I need to enjoy the moment and stop living in the past and worrying about the future.
  • My rise to positions of responsibility was no accident. I’m wired to take on challenges, to bring order and structure, to speak up when others keep their silence, to produce when others believe in the failure of the system, to create new processes and systems of accountability. We spend so much time working on our weaknesses and those weaknesses overcome our emotions and thoughts with self-doubt. A better approach is to identify strengths and leverage those strengths as needed.
  • Crisis Management: When bad things happen in your life you have to be aware of the one simple fact: You can only control what you do to overcome the challenges. The rest is beyond your capability, so do not let it burden you. 
  • On the issue of emotional intelligence, I used to believe that my management experience and leadership positions gave me more self-awareness. Nevertheless and despite my best effort It didn't give me self-management. Furthermore I couldn’t suppress emotions. My face is an open book. I had to and continue to engage my emotions and frustrations before they leave a permanent mark in my face. I used to get feedback from my father about the permanency of my gestures as I got older. Now I understand what he meant.
  • To continue learning new things and applying what I know to my benefit and the organization I represent. To make time to ask and to pursuit answers to technically complex issues affecting our organization. While I cannot expect to be the ultimate expert, I do need to be capable of making high-level decisions with the information provided by those working the front lines of information technology.

Monday, March 05, 2012

Resume Writing and Interviewing


by Victor Alatorre


Resume:
  • Keep your resume clean and readable: avoid crazy fonts or layouts; no color, no pretty logos unless you are a graphic designer.
  • Don’t get cute or exaggerate your accomplishments or skills.
  • No more than a page for entry level experience. HR gets picky about reading wordy resumes.
  • Do tailor your resume to the objectives/requirements of the position you are applying for. For every job application, you should have a resume tailored to their needs.
  • State your education level and GPA (only if it is above a 3.0). It should be your first item. As your career evolves, your education will move beneath your experience. Your GPA should be high enough to allow you to graduate, seek internships, etc. People with low GPA's are usually skipped for opportunities.
  • Avoid Microsoft templates when creating your resume.
  • Avoid cliches and half truths like: "I excel at everything I do. I’m superhuman, I’m smarter than everyone else, I walk on water, I never fail."
  • Stating proficiency as a percentage of your ability.
  • Do use active verbs to describe your accomplishments or responsibilities within each job. Example: Responsible for, created, organized, maintained, developed, collaborated, prepared, provided, designed, etc.
  • Use numbers and figures on size and scope…
  • Member of a team of (state size), responsible for annual sales (state sales), saved the company (state the amount and how).
  • Did you manage, supervise, train, tutor, and/or lead others?
  • Have you been a team leader?
  • Have you trained/mentor someone on his or her new job responsibilities?
  • Have you provided value? How? What were the efforts?
  • Be consistent on your use of bullets and writing style
  • Spelling and grammar issues are important
  • Be specific on your dates of employment. (Avoid using vague season terms: like spring, fall, winter, etc)


Other indirect recommendations


  • Get an internship or two before graduation. Getting experience before graduation is an important element of your success.
  • Use linked-in to develop a network of professional references, network before you need a job, maintain a list of accomplishments online.
  • Volunteer: Make the effort to help others consistently, not just for resume purposes. A one-time event effort does not count as a resume builder. Pick an organization to support and do so.
  • Join a professional organization, and be proactive within the group. Attend meetings, run for office, learn and provide value. When people ask you about your club participation? You should be able to say that you were not only a member, but also an active participant.
  • Social Media can benefit your job search, but it can also cut you. Employers do gather data from social media. Too many party pictures, drinking, having a good time, may provide “additional” information about you. Even if you only share your information with friends; employers have other mechanisms for their disposal.
  • Know what you want when people ask you what do you want to do when you graduate. Match your answer to your credentials.
  • Google yourself. Manage your online presence… Avoid assumptions. Your comments on online forums or opinions do have an impact on your web presence.




Can you demonstrate the following?
Questions employers ask themselves about you:

  • Do you match the qualification requirements?
  • Managers hire for growth not just for the position you are applying. They want to make sure you have what it takes for promotion beyond.
  • Are you trainable, Are you manageable, Are you self-motivated, self-organized, self-aware, self-managed, Are you committed, Are you ethical, Are you worth the effort?
  • Are you consistent on your employment record?
  • Have you had many jobs, terminations, lay offs? (Why?)
  • Is there a gap on your employment? (Why?)

References

Do not assume the people on your references are willing to help you long after you have departed. People move on, People forget your skill set; make sure those that you include on your references can speak about your skill set and talent. Give your references forewarning of what’s to come. Send them your updated resume. Students often assume their professors remember them... They do not (they will not).




Interview
  • Dress appropriately. Dressing up for a fraternity formal is not the same as dressing up for an interview. Avoid black suits, off color suits like yellow, green, brown. Stick to grey or dark blue. Learn to do a double Windsor knot. (No clip-on’s). No visible tattoos or jewelry.
  • Be polite, calm; identify your answers before the interview.
  • Smile, be polite, be gracious, have a good attitude. 
  • No chewing gum, smelling weird, or dirty teeth. (no cologne)
  • Avoid playing with your hands or hair. Do not play with your pan or notebook.
  • Nerves are going to get you to forget questions before you answer. Politely ask to restate the question.
  • Answer questions directly asked… follow the protocol of Q&A. Wait until questions are asked of you. Make sure you answer matches the original question. Sometimes people go off on tangents.
  • Long questions require careful attention… write down the question structure, so make sure you can answer the various elements correctly.
  • When people ask you questions; do have questions about the team, the organization, the position, challenges, etc. Use their response to emphasize your own skill set. If they are struggling with a certain technology or field, restate your expertise
  • Be comfortable with your own skin... Do not try to impress people with a fake persona.
  • Rehearse some answers to usual questions... 
  • Do not play with your hands, your hair, your mouth, etc.